Skeptic Project

So I assume he's an astronomer since he's the expert, right?

Butthurt fringe dork.

His entire argument is that you are not qualified to know if something is bad science or good science, which seems like opinion and nothing else. How can he question your ability to differentiate if you have summarised the original post was nothing to worry about ?

It is a bit like someone being given Darwinian explanations and the creation myth to differentiate, and then deciding that the word of humans writing for a god held more credit and reason. It would not take much thought to be able to differentiate the two, and it would only take a cursory google search to find cursory information if you were unaware.

If you summarised Darwinian evolution was right you would essentially be correct, and would not be expected to reiterate all of Darwin's points to say why, nor would you be expected to explain what level of critical thought you had entered into to differentiate. It would be obvious what critical processes you had used in your answer,and if your conclusion as correct there would be no issues.

Essentially the guy Steve is asking what your critical thought processes are even though your conclusion is likely the correct answer based on historical evidence and scientific thought processes. If he is unable to differentiate the critical thought processes undertaken to arrive at the conclusion then it is likely he is either dimwitted or an intentional antagonist trying to irk you.

I wonder if Steve is a plasma cosmologist as opposed to believing Einsteinian physics ?

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Plasma_cosmology

That's an intellectual insult BTW haha

Agreed with whoever mentioned possible plasma cosmologist. Which means he's not even as qualified as Worfbird because both are amateurs and he is wrong about everything to boot.

UPDATE:

I've come to the conclusion Steve's a troll.

http://www.2012hoax.org/forum/t-411739#post-1309097

I guess because I'm not a smart scientist like he obviously is I can't reply to his post. Fortunately, I have better things to do than feed a troll. I'm going to start image macroing him now.

When the guy has a point to make (regardless of how false or whatnot it is) he gets fairly insulting. I smells a troll...